The Case for Political Action
It is true, unfortunately, that our leadership has betrayed us and that the opposition has been a big disappointment as well. It is true that there are many in the political arena who prefer talk to action, and who really do not care that our people have been left to the wolves. It is true that we are in a state of disorientation, disorganization, and disunity. It is true as well that many of our Arab intellectuals are selling out or selling fairy tales about co-existence and 'peace'. Yes, all that is true, and no rational person would dare call anyone who speaks the truth a "defeatist".
But, what do we do with this bitter knowledge of the truth? Do we succumb to despair or do we try to change it? And how? We must ask these questions because the truth can turn one either into an opportunist or into a revolutionary. If you believe that you are one INDIVIDUAL standing alone, it might appear rational then to try to get the best that you can out of the status quo, i.e., to become a profit-maximizer in negative circumstances. In fact, following this line of individualistic thinking to the extreme can make indifference or even collaboratation with the enemy for the right amount of $$$$$$$$ or privileges appear reasonable.
If you consider yourself part of a people or a nation, on the other hand, you are NOT alone, and it is rational to believe that, with a little hard work and time, perhaps you/we can change the odds. This is why the enemy targets our collective identity. It is only when you/we think you are alone, and act accordingly, that we are doomed to defeat. It is one's reaction to the truth, rather than the indispensable knowledge of the truth that makes one a defeatist.
One might then think: I am but a layman, and can not perform miracles. Quite. But though I may be able to do little things only, I claim that little things can make a BIG difference and that the power of little people is great.
Based on the distinction above between individualistic and group thinking, it becomes vital to TAKE PUBLIC CAUSES PERSONALLY. We need more people who are willing to take Palestine, Iraq, Arab unity, and the struggle against oppression and exploitation everywhere to bed with them. And people like that DO exist, even if they might disagree with each other's views. Unfortunately, we do not have enough people like that yet. We need many more people like that, because there can be no movement for change without a hard core of commitment.
It is here that the question of how, i.e. the question of plotting strategy and building an organization automatically arises. In my humble opinion, we all must renounce the defeatist notion that a strategy or a solution will one day descend upon us from above on a silver platter of magical leadership. The next strategy to succeed must emerge from the interaction of many views and many groups in dialogue and political action. It will not spring forth from the forehead of one individual no matter how great. What is required now is a willingness to interact and cooperate provided that certain red lines are observed, to draw a clear distinction between oneself and the injustice s/he is trying to oppose.
In Response To Defeatist Thought Main Page = = > Click on the logo above and we'll FAV you there :)