Whatever Happened to the Aggregation Problem..

September 29th 2020 | كتبها


One of the biggest challenges before neoclassical economics remains the so-called “aggregation problem” raised by Piero Sraffa and Joan Robinson decades ago which makes a production function for the whole economy highly untenable.

The problem is that most neoclassical conclusions are based on a general production function for the whole economy:

Q= A f(K,L)

where Q is output, A is technology and institutional factors (assumed constant in the short-run), K is capital, and L is labor.

The problem is that whereas output can be theoretically reduced in the aggregate into units of one generic “commodity”, and labor can be reduced into simple labor, e.g., one labor-hour, or workday, capital IN THE AGGREGATE cannot be reduced into one well-defined unit. That is, physical capital, such as plant and especially equipment, varying from manual (such as shovels) to mechanical (such as trains) to electronic (such as computers), CANNOT be reduced into shovels!

If you say we can use the money value of all capital as K instead, then a bigger problem emerges for neoclassical economics: the value of capital depends on its rate of return, which depends on its quantity (due to diminishing returns), which creates an infinite loop in programming language or an element of circularity where the value of something is determined by its value, which is not saying anything at all!

As long as there is no convincing resolution to this question, production functions for the whole economy become flimsy at best, and with them a lot of the conclusions of neoclassical models, including policy implications.

Ibrahim Alloush

Whatever Happened to the Aggregation Problem..One of the biggest challenges before neoclassical economics remains the…

Geplaatst door Ibrahim Alloush op Zondag 27 september 2020

الموضوعات المرتبطة

Two Equations which May Help Explain Why Prices Rise and the US Dollar Appreciates in War-torn Countries under Siege.. Syria as a Case in Point

For people living in countries torn by war, then besieged by stifling sanctions, the issue of rising prices and depreciating local currencies is a very emotional subject which impinges on the very core of their livelihood and the livelihood of their families. Yet it is precisely such dire situations which require an objective understanding of [...]

Real versus Financial Capital: the Fundamental Disequilibrium Destabilizing the Macroeconomy Today

    Technically speaking, the capital value of a publicly-traded firm is equal to the value of its shares, i.e., the value of its market stock. For example, if company X has 1000 stocks (shares outstanding) in circulation, and each is worth $100, then the capital value of that little firm is worth $100,000 if someone wants to buy [...]

Imperialism without Colonies: Even More Relevant after All these Years

  "Imperialism without Colonies" is actually the title of a book by Harry Magdoff whose chapters were written in the sixties and the seventies of the twentieth century. However, the concept conveyed in that book of an imperialism that prefers not to undertake extended occupations has become ever more relevant with the passage of time. It [...]

A Neoclassical Approach to Surplus Value Theory

    Using standard neoclassical textbook microeconomics, one can show that surplus value emerges from consuming labor power by firms even under the strict conditions of perfect competition and diminishing returns to labor. Starting from the first-order conditions for maximizing a profit function, equilibrium in the labor market [...]

Nanotechnology: For Whom, against Whom?

  “Amid the COVID-19 crisis, the global market for Nanotechnology estimated at US $54.2 Billion in the year 2020, is projected to reach a revised size of US$126.8 Billion by 2027” (Globe Newswire, July 15, 2020). Over the last couple of decades, nanotechnology products and devices have become ballooning multi-billion dollar markets. [...]
2020 الصوت العربي الحر.